Transistor

Bitwise builds AND, OR and NOT out of relay contacts in 1937, NOT included: wire a contact so it opens when energised instead of closing, and you have it. A relay will also let a small coil current switch a large one. So the transistor did not make logic possible and did not invent amplification, since both already worked, with moving parts. What a contact cannot do is be half closed. It is open or it is shut, and there is nothing in between. The stage below has a whole region in between, and everything that follows comes from that: it can be an amplifier as well as a gate, and it stops being a gate if you sit it in the middle.

One stage, and the region between fully off and fully on

One stage: a resistor into the base, a resistor from the collector to a 5 volt supply. Move the input and watch what comes out.

current into the base
0.0000 mA
current through the collector
0.00 mA
which is
nothing is flowing
output voltage
5.00 V
which region it is in
cut off

the base is below 0.7 V, so nothing conducts

The same stage across the whole input range. The output falls as the input rises, and it never does otherwise.

Input voltage, base current, collector current, output voltage and which region the stage is in
inbasecollectoroutregion
0.0 V0.0000 mA0.00 mA5.00 Vcut off
0.5 V0.0000 mA0.00 mA5.00 Vcut off
1.0 V0.0064 mA0.64 mA4.36 Vactive
1.5 V0.0170 mA1.70 mA3.30 Vactive
2.0 V0.0277 mA2.77 mA2.23 Vactive
2.5 V0.0383 mA3.83 mA1.17 Vactive
3.0 V0.0489 mA4.80 mA0.20 Vsaturated
3.5 V0.0596 mA4.80 mA0.20 Vsaturated
4.0 V0.0702 mA4.80 mA0.20 Vsaturated
4.5 V0.0809 mA4.80 mA0.20 Vsaturated
5.0 V0.0915 mA4.80 mA0.20 Vsaturated

All 5 checks held when this page loaded.

Read as logic, the same stage is a NOT gate.

Each input level, the voltage it is, the voltage out, and the level that comes out
involts involts outout
00.0 V5.00 V1
15.0 V0.20 V0
the input, as a logic level
0
the output, as a logic level
1
two stages in series
0.0 V in, 5.00 V between them, 0.20 V out

yes, the output is the opposite of the input

One stage turns 0.0000 mA into 0.00 mA and turns the signal upside down doing it. A relay does both of those too. What it cannot do is the row above and the row below: pass a current that is neither nothing nor everything.

What this page checked when it loaded.

Each claim, whether it held, and the values behind it
claimheldmeasured
a low input gives a high outputyes0.0 V in, 5.00 V out
and a high input gives a low outputyes5.0 V in, 0.20 V out
at 1.5 V input and the default gain, active-region collector current is a hundred times base currentyes0.0170 mA in, 1.70 mA out
the output never rises when the input does, across the sweepyes51 points from 0 to 5 V
an inverter driving an inverter is a bufferyes5 V in, 5.00 V out

What is real here, and what is not

This is a silicon textbook stage, and 1947 was neither

The device Bardeen and Brattain built in December 1947 was a point-contact transistor: two gold contacts pressed on a germanium slab, with a small current gain and a habit of dying. Everything on this page (0.7 volts across the base junction, 0.2 volts when saturated, a gain of a hundred) describes the silicon bipolar junction transistor that came later. That is not what “transistor” means today either: almost every transistor now made is a MOSFET, which is voltage-controlled and has no base current to speak of, and the bipolar one is the transistor of a first course in electronics rather than of a modern chip. The date is right for the invention and wrong for the numbers, and it seemed better to say so than to publish a page nobody could compare with a datasheet.

The model is three straight lines, not semiconductor physics

Cut off below 0.7 volts, collector current equal to beta times base current above it, and a ceiling where the collector resistor cannot pass any more. That is enough to show the two facts this page is about and it is not enough for anything else: it has no temperature, no early effect, no leakage, and the transition between regions is a corner rather than a curve. A real device rounds every corner here.

Volts, milliamps and kilohms, so the arithmetic has no hidden thousand

Ohm's law works with no conversion factor in those units, which is deliberate: a stray factor of a thousand is exactly the kind of error that hides on a page like this and still looks plausible. Every number shown is computed from the three constants and the two resistor values, and the base current is never rounded before the collector current is derived from it.

Nothing here is measured from a real transistor

No device was put on a bench for this. The numbers come out of the model, and the model comes out of a textbook. Where the page says the output never rises when the input does, that is a property of the model checked across the sweep when the page loads, not a measurement.

This page used to claim a relay cannot invert, and that was wrong

The first version of it said the transistor did “two things a relay cannot”, control a large current with a small one and invert, and called NOT “the gate relay contacts could not make”. Both halves are false. A relay coil switching a heavy contact load is exactly a small current controlling a large one, and a normally-closed contact opens when energised, which is inversion. Worse, Logical Art’s own Bitwise page says so in as many words: wire a contact so it opens when energised instead of closing, and you have NOT. The page had taken Bitwise’s point about XOR, which really is impossible with plain series and parallel make-contacts, and attached it to the wrong gate. An outside reader found it. The claim now rests on the continuous middle region, which a contact genuinely has no version of, and which is the thing this page draws.

Sources